Ste was the last of us to get his own D&D. He’d played in my first D&D game, where he was a halfling with a dire wolf as a pet, when I started running Red Box Basic but it wasn’t until much later that he got his own rule box and started running games.
This surprised us all. Ste was quite a passive player, generally going along with what others wanted to do and taking an easygoing attitude towards our games. I suspected he wasn’t really that into the whole thing but it’s what his friends did, so he played along. However when Ste’s parents bought him the rules for Christmas he went all in. Ste had two brothers, two sisters, lots of cousins and lived in a large house with lots of space. There were always other kids at his house. Loads of them. Ste began to run D&D for them and he did it a lot. Ste’s game was always on.
Ste was a very permissive DM. He was often running for friends who usually ran games for him, so he took a position very much as referee. He assumed his players knew more about the rules than he did and he simply approved or not the inclusion of ideas they game up with. Mostly he approved. He was running the game every single day, open table style, characters would advance loads and it became a battle to keep up with each other.
His game got extremely high powered very quickly as a result. We often played just one on one or two players, often at lunchtimes at school and frequently with no dice. We were into the domain game before long and this rapidly turned PvP as we competed to control the map of the Known World in the Expert set.
In a territorial masterstroke Jit (not his real name; it was short for Michael McJitland, also not his real name) had built his castle within the walls of the town of Threshold and as a result come to control that iconic settlement. This was much to the annoyance of all the other players. Until my character, Gurak Bloodbath the Fourth (I was eleven years old) destroyed the town with my flight of brown dragons. However Jit rebuilt the town with his vast monetary and supernatural resources, renaming it Stronghold; now with added anti-dragon defences. We all thought this was a genius move and one we were extremely envious of.
Meanwhile Ste’s younger brother Matty and his friend Walty stopped engaging with the rest of the group and began adventuring exclusively together. We didn’t know what they were up to but we suspected they were seeking Paths to Immortality and probably seeking to destroy all other players in the process.
Matty’s character was a ridiculously powerful magic user and one of my strongest allies, so his loss was a great blow to me personally. I didn’t know this at the time but he and Walty were now secretly working against me, and to be fair everyone else, but specifically me because I had access to knowledge that they did not. They were envious and fearful of me because of my esoteric library. While everyone else was still operating at a Basic level, I had surpassed this: I had AD&D.
AD&D gave me a raft of options not available in the basic game. Spells, items and cherry picked rules that Ste allowed me to use to my advantage.
The game continued in this vein, Matty and Walty betrayed me: murdered my dragons and razed my stronghold to the ground. Jit upped the ante by somehow permanently transforming his body into the form of Demogorgon. I stayed up all night on several occasions; like Batman plotting to exploit the weaknesses of each member of the Justice League in turn.
You see, despite total immersion in the game, we were all slowly coming to the conclusion that we missed being able to sit around the same table and play together. So when I finally pulled off my grand plan and slew all the other characters as inventively as I could, no one was that bothered about after the initial shock. The very next week we all went to Ste’s house, rolled up new characters and set off adventuring together again.